Two systems, two very different failure modes
If your garage door has stopped working, the first thing a technician checks is the spring system. Most homes in Valley Village and across the San Fernando Valley use one of two types: torsion springs or extension springs. They do the same job — counterbalancing the door so you can lift it by hand — but they are built differently, mounted differently and fail in completely different ways.
Knowing which one you have helps you understand what happened, what risks are present and what a proper repair involves.
How to tell them apart
Stand inside your garage and look above the door. If you see a horizontal shaft running across the width of the door, with one or two coiled springs mounted on it, you have torsion springs. These springs are anchored at one end and wind up as the door closes, storing energy in the twist. When the door opens, they unwind and release that energy to help lift the door.
If instead you see springs running parallel to the horizontal tracks — stretching from a bracket near the door to a pulley or bracket further back — you have extension springs. These springs stretch as the door closes and contract as it opens. They are usually mounted one on each side of the door.
Some older homes have a single extension spring running above the centre of the door. Either way, the principle is the same: the spring stretches rather than twists.
How each type fails
A torsion spring usually breaks with a loud bang that you can hear from inside the house. The spring splits, often at one of the end coils, and the door suddenly becomes very heavy. If the door is down when it breaks, you may not be able to lift it at all. If it is up, it may come down hard. This is why you should never try to force a door with a broken torsion spring.
An extension spring can also snap, but because it is under tension along its length, the broken halves can travel. That is why safety cables are required through the centre of extension springs — they contain the spring if it breaks. Without cables, a failing extension spring can damage a car, a wall or a person. If you have extension springs and no safety cables, have that addressed before anything else.
In both cases, the door becomes unsafe to operate. Do not pull the emergency release on a door with a broken spring unless you fully understand the risk — the door may drop.
Cycle ratings: what to expect from a spring
Springs are rated in cycles. One cycle is one open and one close. A standard spring for a residential door is typically rated for 10,000 to 15,000 cycles. If your door runs four times a day, that is roughly seven to ten years of service. A door that runs ten times a day will wear out a spring in three to four years.
Higher-cycle springs are available, and for busy households they can be worth considering. A technician can explain the options and quote before any work begins.
Why sizing matters more than most people realise
Springs must be matched to the weight and height of the door. The wire gauge, inside diameter, length and number of coils all affect how much lift the spring provides. A spring that is too strong will make the door feel light and may cause it to open too quickly; a spring that is too weak will leave the door heavy and unbalanced.
Guessing by sight is how doors end up unbalanced. A technician weighs the door or uses the manufacturer's specifications to select the correct spring. This is not a place for trial and error.
Replace torsion springs in pairs
When one torsion spring breaks, the other has usually done the same amount of work. Replacing only the broken spring leaves a new spring fighting an old one. The old spring may fail soon after, and the imbalance can stress the opener, the cables and the door itself. For that reason, torsion springs are replaced in matched pairs. Extension springs are typically replaced in pairs as well, for the same reason.
The one job worth paying for
Winding a torsion spring requires the correct winding bars and a clear understanding of how many turns to apply. Without the right tools and knowledge, the spring can release suddenly and cause serious injury. This is the one garage door repair that is genuinely worth paying a professional to do. Extension springs are less dangerous to replace, but they are still under tension and require care.
If you are in Valley Village, North Hollywood, Studio City, Sherman Oaks, Encino, Van Nuys, Burbank or Glendale, we can inspect your spring system, confirm which type you have, and quote before any work starts. Call (877) 976-2797 or request a quote online.
What to do when a spring breaks
Stop using the door. Do not try to lift it by hand if it feels unusually heavy. Keep children and pets away. If you have extension springs without safety cables, avoid standing in line with the springs. Then call for service. A technician will confirm the spring type, check the cables, drums, rollers and limit switch, and recommend the right replacement. For more detail on torsion spring repair, see our garage door spring repair page.
Common questions
Can I replace just the broken spring? We replace torsion springs in matched pairs, because the second spring has exactly the same hours on it and will fail soon after.
How long should a spring last? Ten to fifteen thousand cycles is typical for a household door, which usually works out at around a decade.
Can I open the door with a broken spring? No. The door is far heavier than the opener expects, and lifting it by hand can drop it on you.